Charges Against Women Accused Of Killing ALS Patient Should Stay, Prosecutors …
October 24, 2015 - als
Two women — one an aged mom and a other a caregiver — should continue to faces charges for conspiring to murder an ALS studious who lived in Solvang, Santa Barbara County prosecutors asserted in a respond to invulnerability motions.
Marjorie Good, 89, and Wanda Nelson, 63, were indicted in a open by a Santa Barbara County grand jury on murder charges in a Mar 2013 genocide of Heidi Good.
She had a neurodegenerative illness amyotrophic parallel sclerosis, also famous ALS and Lou Gerhig’s disease
Good is a mom of Heidi Good; Nelson was one of her caregivers.
In their filings, invulnerability attorneys pronounced a prosecutors unsuccessful to yield grand jurors with information indicating to their clients’ innocence.
But in a response, Deputy District Attorney Aurelia Mattson contended a grand jury was supposing all exculpatory information. Additionally, a invulnerability suit did not embody anything that would lead to a some-more auspicious result, prosecutors said.
“Upon examination of a 33 witnesses’ testimony and 127 exhibits, a grand jury released a complaint opposite defendants Good and Nelson,” a suit said.
Noting mixed inconsistencies in a defendants’ interviews with deputies, a suit also cites available phone calls in that a women plead stealing a fact Marjorie Good knew Nelson’s whereabouts. Nelson replied, “Keep it that way.”
Days after that conversation, Marjorie Good lied to her granddaughter, allegedly observant she had not talked to Nelson in months. Law coercion officers available a call.
Additionally, a charge suit remarkable a defendants immediately blamed Heidi Good’s father for her genocide during mixed conversations with sheriff’s deputies and other.
However, witnesses and navigation apparatus on his work car placed him in Santa Barbara during a time of her death, prosecutors said.
Defense attorneys explain a prosecutors should have told grand jurors that Heidi Good’s father reportedly was due to accept a $350,000 life word payout.
They also contend a grand jurors should have been sensitive Heidi Good’s aged mom had been interviewed for 10 hours straight.
In statute a demeanour of genocide as homicide, experts dynamic Heidi Good had a high turn of remedy in her complement before someone away a ventilator for 30 minutes.
On a day of Heidi Good’s death, Nelson left to run an errand, withdrawal Marjorie Good to watch over a patient. This differed from their standard robe of Marjorie Good doing errands so a caregiver could sojourn with a patient, authorities said.
Tests suggested a ventilator had been away for 30 minutes, a alarm grating and possibly abandoned or unheard by Marjorie Good.
When deputies after conducted a exam of a ventilator with Marjorie Good station outside, she asked, “And what do we hear. Now, would that be a alarm?”
After she concurred a alarm, she claimed a doorway was not open a day Heidi Good died.
“Defendant Good afterwards claimed a doorway was close ‘because it was cold that night,’” according a charge motions, observant deputes reliable it was 71.6 degrees during 2:30 p.m a day of a purported murder.
“Detective Fenske after forked out that suspect Nelson non-stop a doorway when she entered a residence from picking adult a prescription,” a suit noted. “Even yet suspect Good listened a alarm going off during a make-believe where a doorway was open, suspect Good claimed that ‘even with a doorway open we substantially didn’t hear it.’”
The lady has conference troubles, though pronounced she wore a same conference aids a day of her daughter’s genocide and a exam by deputies.
Photos from a stage that day also uncover a bedroom window open, a suit noted.
Nelson also reportedly gave deputies opposing tales about either she listened a alarm when she returned from using a errand.
The caregiver primarily claimed a ventilator was operative properly.
“Defendant Nelson’s chronicle is implausible, as she settled that she walked into Heidi’s room revelation her she was behind while a alarm was going off,” a charge suit said.
“If a alarm was going off, since would she be announcing her participation rather than using to Heidi’s assist as she settled she has finished in a past? It serve disregards a fact that a alarm can be listened from a front door, that suspect Nelson pronounced was open.”
A after examination of information suggested a ventilator was operative properly, with a alarm volume set during a limit of 85 decibels, a charge said.
Prosecutors contend Nelson had financial problems since she was a paid as an eccentric executive while Marjorie Good was going to be kicked out a residence due to steady fights, some of that were physical, with Heidi’s father and son.
- Defense Seeks Dismissal Of Charges Against Women Accused Of Killing ALS Patient, 10.20.15
- Pathologists Conclude Homicide, Not ALS, Ended Heidi Good Swiacki’s Life, 10.10.15
- Bill Macfadyen: Suspected Los Olivos Murder-Suicide Makes a Big Impact on a Small Town, 10.09.15
- Amid Ravages of ALS, Heidi Good Swiacki’s Blog Told Story of Hope, Help and Indomitable Spirit, 10.07.15
- Tragic Tale of ALS Patient Heidi Good Swiacki’s Death Emerges in Criminal Grand Jury Transcripts, 10.05.15
- Trial Date Set For 2 Women Accused Of Killing Solvang ALS Patient, 07.20.15
- Hearing Continued to Jul for Mother, Caregiver Charged in ALS Patient’s Death, 06.19.15
- Arraignment Continued for Mom, Caregiver Charged with Killing ALS Patient, 05.22.15
- Bill Macfadyen: Latest Isla Vista Violence May Be Nothing More Than a Drug Feud, 05.15.15
- Judge Approves Jail Release of Elderly Woman Charged with Killing Daughter Who Had ALS, 05.12.15